When Wisdom Serves the Flesh

When getting what we want becomes more important than glorifying God.

By Summer Martin

Heavy title right?  I’ve currently started a new discipleship group with a few ladies, and we are doing a deep dive into the book of James (one of my homies). And in the studying and researching, I have come across a few different areas that this article will touch on, and wanted to share. 

I’m sure you know some people who are very skilled in getting what they want right? They know which words to use, the emotions to appeal to, when to speak, when to remain silent and how exactly to present a situation in a way that produces the desired result or response. We may even find ourselves impressed in certain situations by those who have this ability to navigate difficult circumstances, but when did this ability to get our own way become the biblical definition of wisdom?

Wisdom is obviously a good thing, yes? When speaking of wisdom that comes from our Godly Father above most certainly. However, James presents us with what can be an uncomfortable distinction between two kinds of wisdom: the wisdom from above and the wisdom that is earthly, unspiritual, and demonic. Who would have thought that not everything that walks, talks, and looks like wisdom actually comes from God?  

And just so you guys don’t just start sharing the article with people you think need to hear this, I want you to take a moment and read the entire thing and let’s examine ourselves first. 

It Begins With Desire

James 1:13-15 makes abundantly clear that God does not tempt us to sin, rather, each person is tempted when he is lured and enticed by his own desire. And desire when it has conceived, gives birth to sin, and sin when fully grown, brings forth death. There are two Greek words in verse 14 that we are going to take a closer look at. 

The first is epithymia (ἐπιθυμία), which means desire, longing, or craving. The word itself does not always refer to something sinful, but in this particular passage, James is addressing desires that entice us toward sin.The second word is exelkō (ἐξέλκω), which means to draw away or lure. It brings to mind the imagery of bait being used to lure something away. And what makes bait effective? It appeals to an existing appetite.

Satan can certainly tempt us and exploit the desires of our hearts, but he does not have to manufacture every temptation we encounter. I mean notice where James lays the responsibility, he doesn’t have us immediately pointing our fingers at Satan, our circumstances, or those people around us, he directs our attention to the desires of our own hearts. 

I do want to point out that some of the desires that we have are not inherently sinful, such as desiring to be loved, understood, respected, included or appreciated. We desire reconciliation in broken relationships, answers to difficult questions, and relief from uncomfortable circumstances. Nothing is necessarily wrong with the desire for those. But what happens when obtaining those desires become more important than honoring God?

That desire may be what is used to tempt us to selectively present information when we want to be understood. Our desire to be loved may tempt us to use guilt to obtain affection; or the desire to be included may tempt us to create division to secure someone’s loyalty. And here’s one, our desire to be right, may tempt us to twist the words of another person. And then all of a sudden, we are no longer simply desiring something, we are willing to sin in order to obtain it. 

And this right here, is where manipulation begins. 

Manipulation as discussed here, is the use of deceptive, coercive, or otherwise sinful means to influence another person or secure a desired outcome. It can be subtle, it can sound reasonable, and it can even be dressed up in spiritual language. But a sinful method does not become righteous simply because we believe the outcome is justified.

Two Kinds Of Wisdom

James asks a question in chapter three that ought to make every believer pause and consider: Who is wise and understanding among you?

He doesn’t answer telling us to look for the person with the most knowledge, the strongest argument, or the greatest ability to influence others, instead he tells us that wisdom is demonstrated through good conduct and meekness. 

He warns us against bitter jealousy and selfish ambition in our hearts, describing wisdom associated with those things as earthly, unspiritual and demonic. Where jealousy and selfish ambition exist, disorder and every vile practice follow. The Greek word translated as selfish ambition in James 3:14 and 16 is eritheia (ἐριθεία). It carries the idea of self-seeking ambition or pursuing one’s own interests. Interestingly enough, Paul uses this same word in Philippians 2:3 when he instructs believers to do nothing from selfish ambition or conceit but, in humility, to count others more significant than themselves. 

That should give us something to chew on. Are we exercising wisdom for the good of others and the glory of God, or are we using what we know to advance our own interests? There is a significant difference between seeking to influence someone toward biblical truth and seeking to influence someone because we want a particular response from them. 

Compare that with James 3:17: “But the wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, open to reason, full of mercy and good fruits, impartial and sincere.”

See that last word there, sincere.  The Greek word is anypokritos (ἀνυπόκριτος), meaning sincere or without hypocrisy. Heavenly wisdom is genuine, it is not putting on one appearance while secretly pursuing another agenda. The wisdom that comes from God doesn’t require us to conceal our intentions, manufacture circumstances, distort the truth, or strategically appeal to someone else’s emotions to get what we want. 

That Heavenly wisdom is open to reason, it doesn’t demand that everyone agree with us. It doesn’t require us to win every disagreement, it is capable of listening, receiving correction, and acknowledging when we are wrong without compromising biblical truth. Someone can be intelligent, articulate, emotionally perceptive, and remarkably skilled at navigating relationships while still operating in earthly wisdom. And cleverness is not necessarily wisdom. Getting the outcome you want is not necessarily evidence of God’s blessing, and being able to influence people does not necessarily mean you are spiritually mature. James measures wisdom by its character and fruit, not merely its effectiveness. 

When We Try To Help God Along

We are going to take a long journey to the left in your Bible if you’ve had it open to the book of James, turn all the way to Genesis 25 and 27 where we take a look at Rebekah. Before Jacob and Esau were born, God revealed to Rebekah that the older would serve the younger. God’s sovereign purpose had already been declared. 

Yet years later, when Rebekah overhears Isaac preparing to bless Esau, she devised a plan and instructed Jacob to disguise himself as his brother, prepares the food Isaac expects, and helps Jacob in the deception of his own father! Jacob receives the blessing, but the deception contributes to devastating consequences within the family. Esau intended to kill his brother, and Jacob was forced to flee. 

Scripture doesn’t reveal every motivation behind Rebekah’s actions, but what it does reveal however, is that God had already declared His purpose, and His purpose was not dependent upon human deception.  But how often are we tempted to do something similar?

We may believe that we know what needs to happen in a relationship, a ministry, or a particular circumstance, and rather than walking in obedience and trusting God with the outcome, we begin by arranging pieces ourselves. We say certain things, withhold others, and attempt to influence people in whatever direction we believe they need to go. We may even convince ourselves that our intentions are godly. But God’s sovereignty does not excuse our sin, and His faithfulness does not depend upon our manipulation. We are responsible for walking in obedience. God is sovereign over the outcome. 

Discernment Begins In The Mirror

As James moves into chapter four, he asks what causes quarrels and fights among believers, and once again, he directs our attention to the desires warring within us. It’s easy to recognize manipulation when we are on the receiving end of it, and it is considerably less enjoyable when Scripture exposes it within ourselves. 

I mean, do we use guilt to get our way? Do we exaggerate circumstances to gain sympathy? Do we withhold communication to punish someone? Do we become angry when people fail to respond the way we expected? Ouch, stepping on anyone’s toes, because mine are aching with that one. Do we selectively share information to ensure others see us as the innocent party? Do we use Scripture to pressure people into doing what we want rather than pointing them to Christ? Or better yet, do we use Scripture out of context to help excuse our actions or feelings?

Biblical discernment requires more than recognizing sinful patterns in others, it also requires the humility to recognize it within ourselves. This does not mean that Christians should be gullible or ignore destructive behavior, Jesus Himself instructed His disciples to be wise as serpents and innocent as doves (Matthew 10:16). We can recognize deception without becoming deceptive, we can establish boundaries without seeking revenge, we can exercise discernment without assuming that we know every hidden agenda in another person’s heart. And we can acknowledge our own temptation to manipulate without accepting responsibility for someone else’s sinful choices. 

And the good news, James does not leave us hopelessly confronting the sinfulness of our own hearts. In James 4:6, he reminds us that God gives more grace. He calls us to humility, repentance, and submission to God. Our hope is not found in becoming more clever, persuasive, or better at controlling our circumstances…..It is found in Christ, whose grace enables us to repent of our sin and pursue obedience. 

I hope this helps us the next time we find ourselves tempted to carefully arrange a conversation, strategically influence someone’s response, or manipulate a circumstance to produce our desired outcome, we should stop and ask ourselves a question. Am I exercising wisdom that comes from above, or am I simply employing worldly wisdom in service to my flesh?

Because biblical wisdom is not about learning how to get what we want. 

It’s about learning to glorify God, even when we don’t. 

Next
Next

El Roi: The God Who Sees Me